Amy McElroy Logo
Amy McElroy
  • About Amy
  • News
  • Training
    • Fair Lane Farm
    • Medal Winners
    • Show Schedule
  • Judging
    • Ask the Judge
    • USEF Judges Evaluations
    • Judging Schedule
  • Home

Ask the Judge

Questions about dressage with Amy McElroy. In Amy’s popular column, written for “The Aiken Horse,” she answers readers questions about dressage.

Ask the Judge – US Dressage Finals

December 14, 2024

By amymcelroy

Dear Amy
This year a group of my riding friends were lucky enough to attend the United States Dressage Finals in Lexington, Kentucky as spectators. It was wonderful to see so many riders from the Aiken area competing. We were really excited on Saturday evening when watching the Grand Prix freestyles in the Alltech Arena to

Continue Reading “Ask the Judge – US Dressage Finals”

Ask the Judge – Seeking Variety

October 30, 2024

By amymcelroy

Dear Amy,My friend and I are adult amateur dressage riders. I ride at First level and my friend at Third level. We both are planning to ride a musical freestyle this fall. We were also interested in the dressage seat equitation classes. We were wondering if you could share any information and advice about things

Continue Reading “Ask the Judge – Seeking Variety”

Ask the Judge – Upper Level Novice

January 31, 2024

By amymcelroy

Dear Amy,  I recently imported an FEI dressage horse from Holland. I am planning to compete with him starting at Prix St. Georges this season in Aiken. I have competed at dressage shows in the past but never at this level, or done any upper level tests. I have a few questions I am curious about, and I have asked around but gotten mixed

Continue Reading “Ask the Judge – Upper Level Novice”

Ask the Judge – Multiple Judges

January 31, 2024

By amymcelroy

Dear Amy, While I competed recently at a local USDF dressage show, I was very surprised to see my show arena had two judges! I was only showing at the lower levels. I thought only more advanced or special shows had multiple judges. So I was wondering if you could you explain the protocol when there

Continue Reading “Ask the Judge – Multiple Judges”

Ask the Judge – Attire Hot Topics

January 31, 2024

By amymcelroy

Dear Amy, I am planning to compete at recognized dressage shows this summer in Aiken. I have a few questions that I hope you can answer for me.  First, with this heat, I am not planning to wear my show jacket, which I know is legal, assuming that jackets are waived at the show. But is it

Continue Reading “Ask the Judge – Attire Hot Topics”

Ask the Judge – Grand Prix Ambitions

May 12, 2023

By amymcelroy

Dear Amy, I am getting ready to move my horse up to the Prix St. Georges level. This winter, I had a chance to watch FEI tests in Florida and I saw there were several versions of the Prix St. Georges (PSG) test being ridden there. Are these classes available at all shows? What is

Continue Reading “Ask the Judge – Grand Prix Ambitions”

Ask the Judge – Ready for 2023

February 3, 2023

By amymcelroy

Dear Amy, I am planning to compete with my horse at Training Level Test Three and First Level Test One this season. I noticed that there have been some changes in the new 2023 versions of these tests and I am hoping you can answer some questions about them. First, I am curious why the

Continue Reading “Ask the Judge – Ready for 2023”

Ask the Judge – Wondering About Judging

July 22, 2022

By amymcelroy

Dear Amy,  I compete regularly at local schooling shows in dressage and combined tests, as well as recognized shows in both disciplines. I am wondering about the judges. Could you explain what the qualifications are to judge at schooling and recognized shows? I am also curious about a score I received for a Beginner Novice

Continue Reading “Ask the Judge – Wondering About Judging”

Ask the Judge – Musical Freestyles

July 22, 2022

By amymcelroy

Dear Amy, I have been a spectator at some of Aiken’s dressage shows this winter. I have especially enjoyed watching all the musical freestyles. I was surprised when some of my favorite rides, with the best music, did not place very high – I thought they would win! Can you explain how these rides are

Continue Reading “Ask the Judge – Musical Freestyles”

Ask the Judge – Confused About Clothes

March 22, 2022

By amymcelroy

Dear Amy, I was recently at a USDF dressage show with a friend of mine. While she was competing, the judge blew the whistle and eliminated her. The judge said this was because my friend’s helmet was not properly secured. This was the helmet she usually competes in, so we were quite surprised she was

Continue Reading “Ask the Judge – Confused About Clothes”

Ask the Judge – 2022 Dressage Rules Update

January 17, 2022

By amymcelroy

Dear Amy, I will be wintering in Aiken this year with my two horses and I am planning to be competing at a few recognized events and dressage shows. Would you please provide an update on any new dressage rules and changes for the 2022 competition year? -Getting Ready Dear Ready, How lucky that you

Continue Reading “Ask the Judge – 2022 Dressage Rules Update”

Ask the Judge – Medals on My Mind

September 12, 2021

By amymcelroy

Dear Amy,I was at a dressage show recently and I heard the announcer congratulating one competitor for earning her Bronze medal, and then another one for earning her Silver medal. I am interested in learning more about these awards. What classes do I need to sign up for to be eligible? Is it the same

Continue Reading “Ask the Judge – Medals on My Mind”

Ask the Judge – Number of Judges

May 31, 2021

By amymcelroy

Dear Amy, At several of our local USDF dressage shows there have been two or three judges’ booths with judges in them for some of the dressage classes. I wanted to know if these classes are judged differently from ones with a single judge? If you have three judges, do you receive all of the

Continue Reading “Ask the Judge – Number of Judges”

Ask the Judge – Attire & Shoulder In

May 31, 2021

By amymcelroy

Dear Amy, I am an adult amateur dressage competitor and will be competing throughout the summer months at Second Level. Although I don’t mind the heat too much, I am concerned about the sun on my skin and eyes. I wondered about the following dress codes. Can I warm up and compete with a wide

Continue Reading “Ask the Judge – Attire & Shoulder In”

Ask the Judge – Proper Salute

March 28, 2021

By amymcelroy

Dear Amy, I recently started competing at the Prix St. Georges level at dressage shows and I am now riding with a double bridle. In the entry of my test I come down the centerline, and halt and salute with a nod of my head. In the final centerline, I halt and salute with a

Continue Reading “Ask the Judge – Proper Salute”

Ask the Judge -Rule Clarifications

November 13, 2020

By amymcelroy

Dear Amy, I was recently a competitor at a USDF dressage show and I watched some other riders’ tests.  I am confused by some of the rulings for decorating mane braids and tail braids, and for riding with seat covers on the saddle and nose nets on the bridle.  I observed several riders who were

Continue Reading “Ask the Judge -Rule Clarifications”

Navigation
  • Home
  • About Amy
  • News
  • Training
    • Fair Lane Farm
    • Medal Winners
    • Show Schedule
  • Judging
    • Ask the Judge
    • USEF Judges Evaluations
    • Judging Schedule
Our Sponsors
the saddle doctor the aiken horse magazine melodie mcgowan saddle fitting Aiken equine vet
Contact

Amy McElroy

Email

Phone: 803-640-4207

Last website update: April 2025

Website Design and Maintenance by Meghan Benge

 

Copyright © 2025 · All Rights Reserved · Amy McElroy

Startup Theme by Organic Themes